Refine suburban micromobility

Design of storage and charging services for micro-mobility
equipment owners in strategic locations in the suburbs

Client

End of Study Project
July 2019 - January 2020

Contribution

Product Design, Exploration, R&D

Team

Project in autonomy

Tools

Figma, Hotjar, Notion, Google Meet,
Google Form, Sheets, Miro...

Residents in suburbs face issues using electric scooters daily, such as laws limiting use, a lack of alternatives in small cities, safety risks, and tension over scooters' place in public areas. How can we encourage the use of electric scooters in suburbs?

CONTEXT

The overrepresentation of car usage in suburban travel

Micro-mobility is big for cities wanting green, less-traffic ways. But in suburbs where cars rule for short trips, it's hard to get people on board with portable micro-mobility like e-scooters and multi-modality. The lack of infrastructure for these can put off folks who stick to cars. Microbilys looks to give parking and storing for micro-mobility rides used for parts of daily travel.

Design process

A user-centered Design Thinking approach.

The design method used is based on user-centered Design Thinking. It involves framing the subject, researching, analyzing data, ideation, design, and evaluation. The design method is based on an iterative model. In this project, I was the only UX Designer and it was my responsibility to contact and include the necessary people for the completion of this project.

RESEARCH

Methodology

To better understand the subject, I first did secondary and competitive research to find current studies, data, and direct or indirect solutions out there. I also interviewed to experts like engineers, officials, sociologists, ethnologists. Next I made a quantitative survey via Google Forms with over 54 people to check or dispute hypotheses and trends in the data. Last, I had 30-45 minute qualitative interviews with 6 owners who regularly use electric micro-mobility gear for daily commutes.

METRIC 1

The micro-mobility market represents $100 to $150 billion in 2023

METRIC 2

42% of French people use their cars due to a lack of alternatives.

METRIC 3

41% of French people desire micro-mobility development.

Sources: According to studies by Ifop and Odoxa from 2018.

Key Findings

In 2020, a large portion of commutes of less than 3 kilometers are done by car due to lack of alternatives. The use of the car is therefore favored by a large portion of French people.Residents in suburbs face issues using electric scooters daily, like laws limiting use, lack of alternatives in small cities, safety risks, and tension over scooters' place in public areas.

However, electric micro-mobility (trips from 0 to 20 km, done with a small dedicated electric equipment) is finding more and more of a place in daily mobility and represents a real alternative. It can cover a large portion of daily trips, but many cities in France cannot benefit from it due to a lack of services and infrastructure for its development. It is also worth noting that this eco-friendly alternative promotes clean and soft mobility, and that demand is increasing.

Survey conducted via Google Form with 54 owners and non-owners of electric micro-mobility device.

During my research, I observed that many electric scooter owners have faced numerous problems, such as some places refusing access to electric scooters even when held by hand. This is because it is considered a motorized vehicle by french law. Additionally, during their daily commutes, many electric scooter owners face the issue of the size and weight of the scooter (≈15 kg). In certain situations, such as rush hour, it is almost impossible to access a train with a scooter in hand.

Insight 1

96%* of peoples would like to use their electric mobility equipment more their daily lives.

* Survey conducted via Google Form with 54 owners and non-owners of electric micro-mobility device.

Insight 2

79%* of peoples use their micro-mobility devices
as a complement to public transportation

* Survey conducted via Google Form with 54 owners and non-owners of electric micro-mobility device.

Insight 3

55%* of peoples don't leave equipement unattended
and unsecured outside.

* Survey conducted via Google Form with 54 owners and non-owners of electric micro-mobility device.

Insight 4

70%** of home-to-work trips less than
3 kilometers are made
by car in France.

** Source: Study conducted by Insee in 2015

Empathy map

To better understand users by focusing on their emotions, needs, attitudes, and environment, the empathy map was used to organize the data collected during the research.

Empathy map created during the research phase to gain a better understanding of users.

Personas

Based on data collected through interviews, quantitative surveys, and secondary research.

Aline B., 31 ans
Serris, France
Recherche d'emploi,
Célibataire
Titre de personalité
Sylvie aime sortir et passer du temps avec sa famille. Le week-end, elle aime faire des balades à vélo et trottinette électrique avec ses enfants.
User story
Sylvie utilise une trottinette électrique pour se déplacer plus facilement, n’ayant pas de voiture. Cependant, certains endroits interdisent l’accès aux trottinettes électriques, ce qui l’empêche de les utiliser pour certains types de déplacements.
Peurs & frustrations
- Trottinette lourde et encombrante.
- Risque important si l'équipement est laissée à l'extérieur sans surveillance.
- Incivilités de dégradations ou de vols.
- Utilisation contrainte du bus ou de la voiture pour de courts trajets faisable avec un équipement de micro-mobilité.
Biographie
Sylvie habite en banlieue de Paris, à Serris. Elle a acheté trois trottinettes électriques pour elle et ses enfants, afin de se promener ou d’effectuer de courts trajets quotidiens, car elle n’a pas le permis de conduire.
Besoins & objectifs
- Se promener en trottinette électrique avec ses enfants dans les alentours.
- Économiser du temps et de l’argent en utilisant sa trottinette électrique.
- Gagner en liberté de déplacement pour compenser le fait de ne pas avoir de permis.
- Pouvoir garer ses trottinettes électriques dans des lieux sécurisés et accessibles.
- Besoin de recharger sa trottinette électrique de temps en temps.
Fabien L., 32 ans
Vincennes, France
CSP+, Marié
Titre de personalité
Technophile, eco-anxieux et stressé, Fabien recherche des moyens pour participer à son échelle à la réduction des émissions de Co2.
User story
En tant qu’employé, je voudrais pouvoir me rendre à la gare de Vincennes en trottinette, et pouvoir la déposer dans un lieu sécurisé et pratique pour m’en débarrasser.
Peurs & frustrations
- La trottinette électrique est encombrante et lourde dans les transports au quotidien.
- Elle n’est pas acceptée dans certains lieux.
- Le stockage est gênant sur le lieu de travail.
- Peur de se faire dégrader ou voler sa trottinette électrique en l'attachant sur la voie publique et sans surveillance.
Biographie
Fabien est un expert en SEO dans une grande entreprise à Paris. Il utilise sa trottinette électrique pour se rendre à la gare RER de Vincennes chaque jour de la semaine.
Besoins & objectifs
- Faire l’aller-retour de son domicile à la gare RER de Vincennes du lundi au vendredi.
- Garer sa trottinette électrique en sécurité afin de s’en désencombrer dans le RER.
- Une solution fiable, sécurisé et facile à prendre en main pour ne pas prendre de temps le matin.
Brice M., 20 ans
Seine-Saint-Denis, France
Étudiant, Célibataire
Titre de personalité
Cultivé et curieux, il est adepte des déplacements en skateboard et en trottinette électrique.
User story
En tant que futur propriétaire d’une trottinette électrique, Brice souhaite trouver des solutions avant d’acquérir sa propre trottinette, et répondre ainsi aux questions qu’il se pose avant l’achat. L’établissement interdit l’entrée des trottinettes électriques.
Peurs & frustrations
- Trottinette électrique lourde et encombrante.
- Peur chaque jour de se faire voler sa trottinette en la garant devant la FAC.
- Incivilités de personnes pouvant causer des dégradations/vols.
- Les intempéries comme la pluie, la neige ou la chaleur peuvent causer des dommages.
Biographie
Brice est un étudiant en FAC de médecine à Bobigny. Du lundi au vendredi, il loue une trottinette électrique depuis 3 mois, mais il envisage d’acheter une trottinette électrique privée, car c’est plus économique.
Besoins & objectifs
- Garer sa trottinette dans un endroit sûr.
- Se libérer de sa trottinette à la FAC.
- Recharger son équipement pour le retour.
- Se rendre rapidement à la FAC le matin.
- Trouver un système sécurisé pour éviter le vol de sa trottinette.

Ideations

Opportunities

The lack of solutions to develop and promote soft micro-mobility as a substitute for cars in the suburbs creates a need that must be addressed through design.

Mindmap used to enhance the ideation phase in the search for solutions.

A complete solution will have to take into account: a secure system for equipment monitoring, a network of stations developed to cover the entire territory, a quick, easy, and convenient use to adapt to all daily usage contexts, and finally a cost of service acceptable for regular use.

Iterations

Iterations

To find the most suitable solutions, numerous iterations with physical prototypes were designed to envision the most practical solutions that meet real-world usage constraints. For this project, I met with engineers to validate or invalidate technical possibilities. This helped save time on feasibility and find sometimes simpler and less costly solutions.

Secure, organize, and develop
micro-mobility.

Unsure which approach would develop more trust and lead to more conversions,
I created user flows for both a long and a short onboarding experience,
with the goal of testing the two approaches.

Prototype for publish button animation alongside treatments for status indicators

Conclusion

Impacts and projections for the future

The proposal for this service has sparked the interest of many organizations during its presentation, including Bouygue Immobilier, which intends to implement it in its future connected real estate complexes.

The Grand Paris 2024 project has also shown interest in offering an additional mobility solution for the 2024 Olympic Games in Paris. This would allow for an environmentally responsible mobility solution.

Lastly, the interest of KissKissBankBank, a pioneer in crowdfunding in France, prompted me to propose this project to "Skoda," who was seeking projects to support in the field of micro-mobility.

A major topic of eco-responsibility

Microbilys makes micro-mobility
more accessible
to everyone.

Expressing heartfelt thanks goes to Mr. Laurent Gago, the instructors at e-artsup Paris, Mickaël Bétremant (co-director of WestonMills communication agency), Mr. Karim Aït Abderrahim (head of the "energy" laboratory at ESME), and Lorie Payet (Proofreading and correction).